Study Shows Students Favor Privacy Over Enhancing Library Collection and Services
Privacy is an inherently complex and challenging topic to get a handle on made even more complicated by the almost daily changes in technology, legislation, and government activity that surround the issue. (It was recently revealed that the government is now opening private mail.) Adding to the confusion is trying to understand the extent to which people actually value their privacy. Although librarians have in general been steadfast in their support of user privacy as a core principle, personal blogs and complacency in the face of corporate use of personal information has led some to declare the the concern for privacy is dead or in at least in a coma. Recently, however, there have been some signs that the patient is waking up.
A 2005 study by Steven Johns and Karen Lawson provides some hard numbers to gauge student attitudes about privacy and the library. In the debate between personalization and privacy only 23% of students at Iowa State University felt that “developing student profiles for the purpose of enhancing the Library’s collection and services constituted justifiable use.” So before you go bibliomining your circ database or developing a user community around archived email reference questions, you may want to check out “University undergraduate students and library-related privacy issues” in Library & Information Science Research, 27 (Sept 2005) 485-495.
Posted: January 11, 2006 by Marc Meola
in Privacy.
Comments
Comment from Barbara Fister
Posted: January 12, 2006 at 6:44 pm
Interesting – thanks for pointing this out. I will look the article up since I’m interested in how the survey was worded, since I imagine that would play a significant role in how it would be answered.
A recent IPSOS survey conducted for the Associated Press found the majority of US citizens think warrants should be secured before the government conducts surveillance – but what’s spooky is that it’s not a very big majority. I think the wording of the question was a factor, since it was very specific to the government’s claim it is only monitoring calls between citizens as suspected terrorists abroad. Their press release headline is more colorful and inflected, referring to “snooping.”
It’s all in how you ask the questions.
Pingback from ACRLog » Blog Archive » Facebook news feed backlash reveals student privacy concerns
Posted: September 7, 2006 at 10:17 am
[...] The Wall Street Journal (free) reports that students are “outraged” over two new features in Facebook called News Feed and Mini Feed. The features “track users’ actions on the site and then keep all of their friends apprised of those developments.” Students are angered that information that they thought was private became public overnight. This adds to the evidence that privacy is only mostly dead and not completely dead. [...]
Comment from GenY Librarian
Posted: January 11, 2006 at 5:12 pm
>”developing student profiles for the purpose of enhancing the Library’s collection and services constituted justifiable use”