A Born-Digital Librarian’s Reflection on Digital Educational Tools

Editor’s note: We welcome a guest blog post from Senka Stankovic, Head of User Services at the Jean-Léon Allie Library, Saint-Paul University.

As an early-career librarian halfway through a year-long parental leave contract at Saint Paul University, I’ve noticed that digital tools are fundamental to how we ideate and deliver educational workshops. Born-digital, recently a student, and new to the workforce, I’ve come to believe that many digital tools that are meant to improve learning instead strip away the friction that the acquisition of knowledge requires.

In this post, I explore three common classroom technologies: the slide deck, the laptop, and the gadgets[1]. I present how these so-called “tools” often get in our way, and I offer opportunities for reintroducing friction to the classroom in the classroom in the form of minor inconveniences. This friction can lead to higher engagement from, and connection with, our learners.

I believe librarians are in a unique position to pioneer a more hopeful use of technology in the classroom and beyond.

The slide deck

The slide deck is ubiquitous in academia and in white-collar work. In the classroom, slide decks turn teaching into a presentation where we strive for perfection. This is in part because slide decks, meant for presentations, allow educators to over-prepare their courses. If you’re presenting something you know well, then your slide deck is there to make sure you don’t veer off course. But off course is where you get to show students your own fallibility, which helps build meaningful connections through vulnerability. It also gives your students a framework for managing the friction that things like research inevitably create. In other words, your slide deck prevents you from modeling educational resilience by giving you something to hide behind.

Adding friction to the slide deck includes taking the time to ask whether a slide deck is the right method of sharing the information at hand. I find that very often, it isn’t. At my university, I’m responsible for delivering one-on-one Academic Integrity Workshops to students who have committed plagiarism. I was unsatisfied with the presentation-style workshop I had inherited, as I felt myself lecturing at students who were either on the verge of tears or completely oblivious as to their wrongdoings. In neither scenario were they primed for learning. I adopted a new approach that includes a self-assessment on their behalf and a print workbook where they can take notes. I still use a monitor where needed, such as demonstrating tools they can use for research instead of ChatGPT. My new approach has so far been fruitful. I’ve not had any tears since adopting it.

When you remove the slide deck from the equation, you make room for more creative methods. I saw this in April, when I attended a session at the British Columbia Library Association Conference titled “Throwing Out the PowerPoint: An Experiential Learning Approach.” Adair Harper, Chloe Riley, and Julia Lane replaced their library orientation slide deck with a zine and an accompanying exercise to help students learn to navigate library resources. Their new approach seems more communal in nature, and I’m curious to see what can happen when we start questioning why things are done the way they are.

The laptop

The laptop and the expectation that students all have one are detrimental to everyone’s learning. Besides the obvious financial inequity factor, laptops are also hugely distracting. As a student, I was frequently sidelined by the person in front of me watching Euphoria or tweaking their resume. I’m sure that my compulsive opening and scrolling of Pinterest every time I open a browser also distracted many folks sitting behind me.

Recently, I read about Dylan Kane, a middle-school math teacher and early adopter of Chromebooks in classrooms who has decided to jump ship. In removing laptops from his classroom for a month, Kane learned that “screens […] made it possible for a student to look busy for an entire class period” without him realizing they were stuck on a problem. In other words, learning is hard, scrolling on Pinterest is easy. Think of your own life. How often do you come head-to-head with something you find difficult and pull out your phone to avoid it? If we can’t muster the self-control needed to not use screens as pacifiers, how can we expect students not to do so when faced with the friction of learning?

Expecting all students to be fluent in laptops is also a barrier to those with less technological experience. Catherine Carroll, a mature student at Saint Paul’s University, describes her return to academia as a huge learning curve by way of technology. “It gets in the way of learning the actual material,” she says.

Adding friction to the laptop might look like encouraging writing by hand and taking the time to show students how to search the stacks. While these skills may not be frequently applied, I believe it would be beneficial. Born-digital students would be given an alternative, more tactile, framework for engaging with information. This may increase their attention to how information is created, accessed, and shared in the digital realm by giving them a point of comparison. On the other hand, mature students would be given permission to engage with knowledge in a way that works better for them.

The gadgets

Learning gadgets that advertise increased engagement reduce tactility and thereby advocate for the disembodiment of learning. Many of these tools are nothing more than a digitization of existing classroom activities. Miro is literally a virtual blackboard. With Quizlet, you can create digital flashcards, rendering the educational process of handwriting them obsolete. Kahoot replaces good, old-fashioned pen-to-paper trivia. They take away moments where students might otherwise be forced to write or move around in their learning environments.

Additionally, all these tools are privately owned by for-profit companies. This doesn’t sit well with me, as using them requires students to give out personal information in the form of email addresses or browsing data.

The friction of distributing papers to participate in an activity or having students physically get up to add ideas to a blackboard reintroduces a dynamism to learning that can pull us all out of the digital funk created by many learning technologies.

On the advantages of digital educational tools

The tools I mention have advantages. Laptops and slide decks both offer accessibility features, and removal of these technologies may lead to access friction – not the kind we’re going for – for learners with disabilities. The gadgets might encourage engagement, provide immediate feedback to learners, and provide educators with additional insights into their students’ knowledge.

The complete abandonment of digital technologies isn’t attractive to most of us, nor would it promote equitable access to information. Nonetheless, I believe that treating digital tools as a gold standard in education can be detrimental and limits our ability as educators to think creatively about the knowledge we share. By reflecting on ways to add helpful friction, while maintaining a balance for those that require assistive technology or prefer digital learning tools, we can create more positive learning environments.

A way forward

Adding friction to slide decks, laptops, and gadgets is a strong starting point to rebuild meaningful classrooms that center knowledge acquisition. It’s also a sign of hope that the world I want to live in is possible, one where learning is communal, present, and embodied. Librarians are in a unique position to advocate for the friction that learning requires, even when that means experiencing the friction of learning themselves.

In an interview, Kurt Vonnegut describes purchasing envelopes one at a time so that he has more opportunities to exist in the world. His wife believes it to be an inconvenience. He concludes, “And, of course, the computers will do us out of that. And, what the computer people don’t realize, or they don’t care, is we’re dancing animals.” For me, the image of librarianship that elicits joy is one with room to dance. Or fumble, or add friction, or whatever you so choose to call it.


[1] I use gadgets to loosely refer to novelty items aimed at digitally increasing student engagement. Some examples include Miro, a virtual blackboard; Quizlet, for digital flashcards; Kahoot, for quizzes and trivia; and Mentimeter, for polling. These attempts to reintroduce tactility in the classroom are simulacral.

The Chatbot Will See You Now: Concerns about Artificial Intelligence and Medicine

Editor’s note: We welcome a guest blog post from Rebecca Kyser, Research and Instruction Librarian at Himmelfarb Health Sciences Library, The George Washington University.

Disclaimer: All opinions expressed in this post are the author’s own and do not represent her place of work.

As a medical librarian who specializes in medical misinformation and disinformation, I tend to have a healthy skepticism for cure-alls. So when I first heard about AI’s promises of automating workflows, eliminating repetitive tasks and curing disease, my first thought was to investigate exactly how true they were. It’s been around four years since then but I’ve emerged from this process to find myself firmly an AI skeptic, especially in regards to large language models (LLMs). And to my disappointment, I’ve found LLMs frequently cited as a solution to solve countless problems of medicine. 

With that in mind, I wanted to share some of my concerns about AI being integrated into medical technology. Not all of these issues are exclusive to medicine – many are found in any field that AI touches – but some of the consequences of AI behaving badly get far worse when people’s health is involved. 

AI is Inaccurate

At this point, almost everyone has heard about AI hallucinations: instances where AI makes up false information. Hallucinations are baked in the technology: there is no way of getting rid of them entirely 1. Rates of false answers vary from model to model 2, and the rate is often published by independent assessors, rather than the companies themselves. The best response to this problem is to lower the rate as much as possible.

However, when we’re talking about wrong answers regarding medical information, what threshold of inaccuracy do we find acceptable? Hallucination rates of 39.6% 2 may be acceptable when asking a bot about the weather, but would we consider that rate acceptable, or even a 10% hallucination rate, for a doctor prescribing you medicine? This isn’t to say humans don’t make medical errors – there’s plenty of scholarship on the topic and how to prevent it – but are their error rates comparable with a bot?

The error rate isn’t great at the moment. Multiple studies have shown chatbots make mistakes regarding medical queries: surgical errors leading to patient injury 3, undertriaging cases 4 and providing faulty medical advice to the public 5. Those mistakes aren’t small outliers either: ChatGPT undertriaged cases 52% of the time 4 and provided correct relevant conditions in less than 34.5% of cases5. 

There is the argument that as AI gets better (which is an assumption worth investigating), this will cease to be an issue. However, even if AI had an accuracy rate equal or less than humans, another problem arises: who can be held liable for medical error when the error comes from a machine? Is it the person operating the machine or the person who built it? Without these kinds of clearly defined policies, addressing mistakes with AI in medicine becomes a thorny business. 

Garbage in, Garbage Out

Most people know that LLM are trained off broad swaths of information online, but I don’t think we always consider exactly what that entails. Without having access to these models’ training data directly, we can only make educational guesses on what the training data entails, usually by looking at outputs and trying to reverse engineer their source. This is something I’ve done myself: if you have access to an AI that provides sources, ask it about a headline from Alex Jones’ infamous platform Infowars and watch it regurgitate it back to you.

A picture of a headline from Alex Jones Infowars website, showing Terminator-style robots with the headline Humanoid Soldiers Tested in Ukraine; Founder Eyes Contract To Patrol US Border
A picture of a headline from Alex Jones Infowars website, showing Terminator-style robots with the headline “Humanoid Soldiers Tested in Ukraine; Founder Eyes Contract To Patrol US Border”

There is an argument this is remedied by ensuring the model only works off high quality training data. The problem is, we often don’t know exactly what was in the training data to begin with. Even if a model claims to be based on entirely scholarly sources, we should understand all the nuances of what that means: are all the sources peer-reviewed? Does the training set have safeguards against poor-quality sources from predatory publishers? Are retracted publications excluded from the training data? Is the data set monitored for works that are retracted after they enter the training data?

I think the best way to demonstrate this problem is to examine one of the few cases we’ve seen under the hood for a LLM: Claude. Due to a lawsuit, a database was published containing books Claude was trained off of, which the public can access. 

One of the names that comes up in the training set is Graham Hancock. For those who don’t recognize the name, Graham Hancock is a pseudohistorian, who often argues that the work of ancient civilizations was actually built by aliens. His inclusion isn’t surprising – his work is incredibly popular and Claude debunks his theories if asked – but it does raise concerns about the training data for these models. Especially when there are more concerning inclusions, such as the work of Richard Lynn, who can also be found in the data set. 

Richard Lynn was a well known scientific racist, known for promoting pro-eugenic ideas up until his death in 2023. Why is a scientific racist’s work fed into this model?  If this model is being trained to answer questions, why does it have disproven scientific racism in it? You can’t argue its inclusion is due to popularity; unlike Hancock, only one of these publications is well known enough to even have its own Wikipedia page, and that page is mostly about its racist background 6.

I use Lynn as an example because of the history of scientific racism in medicine. Many medical AI attest to training only off medical publications or scholarly journals, but that does not mean those are free of false or harmful ideas. Lynn is an example of this: he published multiple works promoting scientific racism 7. How do we ensure this kind of work doesn’t end up in these models? And is anyone actually looking out for them?

Bias

Many people like to think machines aren’t biased, but that simply isn’t true. Machines are built by humans who contain a wide variety of biases, and those biases get filtered down into both our creations and the data we feed them. A really good example of this is from ProPublica’s investigation of recidivism calculators, which declared Black people at higher risk of offending than white people, even when the white person had a lengthier criminal record. 8 

This is also an issue in medicine. One of the most common mistakes I see in these machines when it comes to medicine is anchoring bias: the bias to assume your first assumption is right. For example, when I asked an AI model for medicine for a differential diagnosis for a patient experiencing chest pain, it suggested cardiac causes. However, when I asked the same question but stated the patient had a history of anxiety, the differential shifted entirely to psychological causes. 

What’s likely happening here has to do with the training data: these models are being fed on content like textbooks, case reports and other educational content. A classic case presentation often gives the reader the information they need to make a diagnosis but might leave out superfluous details that a patient might give in real life. Since the bot is unused to seeing those details outside of cases where they are important, it sometimes anchors on the wrong idea. This may explain why the accuracy rate fell so drastically when it came to doctors inputting information over patients: the doctors knew what information was clinically relevant, the patients did not. 5

No Free Lunch

While many LLMs are free to access at the moment, it seems unlikely that they will remain so. The power and processing power required to run these LLMs is significant and these companies are not non-profits. Which raises a question: how will these companies make money anyway? As the old economic saying goes, there is no free lunch. 

Currently, that’s a question without an answer: OpenAI, the owner of ChatGPT, is still running at a loss and isn’t expected to turn a profit until 2029. 9 They have announced planned revenue streams involving integrating their product into their software (think of an LLM embedded into Word or another consumer product)10, but I want to focus on three potential answers to this revenue problem in particular.

The first revenue option is subscriptions: most AI companies already offer fee-based options such as early access to newer versions of the model or custom-built models with training data specified by the user. Which raises an issue common in subscription models: the cost of access. The inflationary costs of scholarly journals and publications have long posed a problem for library budgets; what happens when we add AI subscriptions to the mix? Will access to the latest AI models widen inequities in education?

Another likely answer to the revenue problem is advertisements. There is a long history of web platforms turning to advertisers to generate revenue when users are reluctant to pay for a service. This might seem more obnoxious than harmful, but the stakes when advertising medical interventions are much higher than those in marketing new shoes. Marketing to doctors fertilized the seeds of the Opioid Crisis, and we should consider the ramifications of Open Evidence- an AI platform that advertises itself to medical professionals- potentially advertising some drugs over others (this idea is explored fully in an excellent post from the Krafty Librarian)

We also have to consider a revenue stream most commonly used by social media sites: the sale of user data to advertisers. Of course, there is a hiccup here: individually identifiable health information is protected under HIPAA and cannot be disclosed. But that doesn’t mean data can’t be used if it is anonymized.

Let’s try an example. In this hypothetical, let’s say there’s a small town in Southern Colorado that suffers from a pollution issue that leads to interstitial respiratory disease. Medical professionals in the area are shown to ask one AI company queries regarding this condition and how to treat it at a higher rate than the rest of the country. The AI Company then sells this data, which while anonymized, shows this community suffers from this issue.

Here are some potential buyers:

  • A supplement company coming out with a tonic to soothe chronic cough. They place advertisements for this area around the symptoms of interstitial respiratory disease and claim it is a “natural option” to treat the condition. Their sales boom.
  • An insurance provider for the area buys the data. Realizing they will be seeing a spike in claims for some treatments before those claims even enter their system, they amend clinics patients can go to in order to cut costs. Less people are able to access health care.
  • A pharmaceutical company takes out advertisements for their latest drug to treat chronic cough. Patients start requesting this drug at local medical providers after being told it’s “the best” despite there being a cheaper generic. 
  • A company that wants to cut corners with their air filters buys land in this area, knowing their additional pollution may not be noticed as quickly.

And so on, and so forth. While companies can already do some of these things by tracking data of searches via Google, the consolidation of demographic information under medical providers would make the task much easier. Are such privacy violations really worth saving a few minutes? 

I don’t wish to cast an entirely bleak view of artificial intelligence in medicine, despite my list above. There are potential use cases with narrow AI; AI trained to do one specific task. However, I recommended a healthy level of skepticism whenever interfacing with an AI product. “Move Fast and Break Things” might be the motto of Silicon Valley, but we cannot let breaking people become a standard practice in medicine.

Acknowledgements: Thank you to Brie McDonald for help editing this piece.

References

1. Nicola Jones. AI hallucinations can’t be stopped — but these techniques can limit their damage. Nature Web site. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-00068-5. Accessed 3/17, 2026.

2. Chelli M, Descamps J, Lavoué V, et al. Hallucination rates and reference accuracy of ChatGPT and bard for systematic reviews: Comparative analysis. J Med Internet Res. 2024;26:e53164. https://www.jmir.org/2024/1/e53164https://doi.org/10.2196/53164http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/38776130. doi: 10.2196/53164.

3. Jaimi Dowdell, , Steve Stecklow, Chad Terhune, and, Rachael Levy. As AI enters the operating room, reports arise of botched surgeries and misidentified body parts. https://www.reuters.com/investigations/ai-enters-operating-room-reports-arise-botched-surgeries-misidentified-body-2026-02-09/. Updated 2026. Accessed 3/17, 2026.

4. Ramaswamy A, Tyagi A, Hugo H, et al. ChatGPT health performance in a structured test of triage recommendations. Nat Med. 2026. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-026-04297-7. doi: 10.1038/s41591-026-04297-7.

5. Bean AM, Payne RE, Parsons G, et al. Reliability of LLMs as medical assistants for the general public: A randomized preregistered study. Nat Med. 2026;32(2):609–615. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-025-04074-y. doi: 10.1038/s41591-025-04074-y.

6. IQ and the wealth of nations, Wikipedia Web site. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_and_the_Wealth_of_Nations. Updated 2026. Accessed 3/17, 2026.

7. Dan Samorodnitsky, Kevin Bird, et al. Journals that published richard lynn’s racist ‘research’ articles should retract them. https://www.statnews.com/2024/06/20/richard-lynn-racist-research-articles-journals-retractions/. Updated 2024. Accessed 3/17, 2026.

8. Julia Angwin, Jeff Larson, Surya Mattu and Lauren Kirchner. Machine bias. ProPublica. 2016. https://www.propublica.org/article/machine-bias-risk-assessments-in-criminal-sentencing.

9. Craig S. Smith. What large models cost you – there is no free AI lunch. Forbes Web site. https://www.forbes.com/sites/craigsmith/2023/09/08/what-large-models-cost-you–there-is-no-free-ai-lunch/. Updated 2023. Accessed 3/17, 2026.

10. Dave Smith. OpenAI says it plans to report stunning annual losses through 2028—and then turn wildly profitable just two years later. Fortune Web site. https://fortune.com/2025/11/12/openai-cash-burn-rate-annual-losses-2028-profitable-2030-financial-documents/. Updated 2025.

Rethinking Wikipedia from a Library Perspective

Editor’s note: We welcome a guest blog post from Nathan Sonnenschein, User Services & Experience Librarian at Montana State University Billings.

During my first year as an undergraduate, my community college’s library handed out folders bearing a catchphrase: “Faster than Google. Better than Wikipedia. Your college library.” This gave me the impression that academic libraries saw Wikipedia as a usurper on their terrain—an upstart competitor of the digital age. This struck me as out-of-touch. I had to start my research somewhere, and Wikipedia was an easy, familiar way to learn the essentials about a topic before searching the library for books or articles. Furthermore, checking Wikipedia’s citations helped me find crucial sources I might have otherwise missed. I never would have cited Wikipedia directly in my papers, but then again, I would never have cited any encyclopedia.

In the decade since, I have been delighted to see many library professionals develop more nuanced approaches to Wikipedia. Past ACRLog posts reveal a few of these perspectives. Wikipedia is a handy partner for brainstorming, a clever means for disseminating new research, and a great case study for teaching info-lit students about systemic biases or the facets of the ACRL Framework. Many libraries over the years have even hosted edit-a-thons and other initiatives to promote active, critical engagement with the online information landscape.

Still, the belief that Wikipedia has no place in research or scholarship persists. Many of my students’ zealous high school teachers taught them to never use Wikipedia, ever. To be fair, Wikipedia is far from perfect. Its mechanisms can and do enable vandalism (though editors often revert vandalism within a few hours, or even a few minutes). Readers must watch out for uncited statements or promotional language. For new editors—Wikipedia’s term for its contributors—the site’s policies and style guidance can feel frustratingly arcane and difficult. Wikipedia’s editor base skews heavily white and male, which introduces the potential for unconscious bias, and can create an alienating environment for editors who are women and/or people of color. These are real issues, but they do not mean Wikipedia has no valid place in the information ecosystem. Any information source has its strengths and weaknesses, and we must approach all sources with a critical lens.

Optimistically, I hope the library field has reached a place where most of us understand how great Wikipedia is for certain uses. However, we need to go further. In our new world of generative AI and volatile American politics, our fields must approach Wikipedia as not just a tool, but as an ally. Let me explain.

A shared mission

Generally, the digital revolution in the library sector has been intertwined with the trends of corporate growth and consolidation. Academic libraries’ collection development funds funnel almost entirely to massive publishers and “information cartels.” These companies have a vested interest in keeping information behind paywalls, and in protecting their own rights. This pursuit of profit is actively at odds with our libraries’ economic realities—with flatlined or diminishing budgets, serving our communities’ information needs is increasingly challenging. (Quite frankly, it feels unethical to subsidize these corporations’ profit margins with the limited funds my library receives—especially when that funding comes from student fees.)

In contrast, Wikipedia is run by the Wikimedia Foundation, a nonprofit organization that seeks to “help everyone share in the sum of all knowledge.” (This is a big reason why Wikipedia has not suffered from the enshittification plaguing Google Search and other platforms.) The library field and the Wikimedia Foundation are both rooted in the belief that individuals benefit from information access. We are not competing, but working toward the same vision. As library professionals, we are not seeking to enrich our institutions by boosting profits. We are seeking sustainable mechanisms for keeping our communities connected to information.

The political climate

Just as libraries and Wikipedia have similar goals, we are facing similar challenges. On April 24, 2025, the Wikimedia Foundation received a letter from the U.S. Department of Justice claiming the organization may have violated nonprofit laws. Why? The letter levels several accusations: spreading propaganda, rewriting the details of events in American history, and failing to provide “neutral” educational content—content that allegedly benefits foreign powers. The inference is that Wikipedia must engage readers with a point of view that directly favors the United States, and should not even have “foreign nationals” on its board, despite Wikipedia’s international scope. 

One passage in particular sticks out to me: “Masking propaganda that influences public opinion under the guise of providing informational material is antithetical to Wikimedia’s ‘educational’ mission.” If you swap “Wikimedia” for “libraries,” this statement rings similarly to the accusations unrelentingly leveled against libraries over the past few years. Whether it be the supposed spread of anti-American narratives, the “indoctrination” of children via books with queer themes, or the dissemination of scholarly materials on Critical Race Theory, libraries are challenged for providing information that does not align with the agenda of certain powerful political factions. While the DOJ’s accusations against Wikipedia differ in form from the censorship pressures faced by libraries, the underlying logic—targeting institutions for disseminating perspectives that do not align with a certain political agenda—is strikingly similar. The result? Even as federal library grants are revoked, the Wikimedia Foundation has its nonprofit status threatened.

The rise of AI

The information landscape is quickly shifting as generative AI tools, like ChatGPT and Google Gemini, are revolutionizing information discovery. For libraries, this just means adapting to yet another wave of technological innovation. However, because Wikipedia is relatively young, its resilience is being tested. There has already been some doom and gloom about Wikipedia’s continued existence in a world where AI can conveniently provide encyclopedic information. Yet, many AI platforms are heavily dependent on information sourced from Wikipedia (and from libraries’ digital collections, for that matter). This creates a new paradigm: an information landscape where AI-generated information proliferates, but traditional, human-generated sources—primary, secondary, and tertiary alike—take on a new dimension of reliability and authority. The latter cannot exist without the former.

In other words, with so much machine-generated content on the internet, Wikipedia’s content takes on new value. The Wikimedia Foundation recently reaffirmed its commitment to “putting humans first.” On the editing side, this means relegating AI to technical tasks while continuing to rely on real people for knowledge curation. For the everyday reader, Wikipedia remains committed to creating for the sake of human learning, not for AI ingestion. Meanwhile, libraries continue to exist for the purpose of serving people, prioritizing access, privacy, and reliability. To say that another way, Wikipedia and libraries put people first—not for the sake of profit, but for the betterment of society.

What does this mean?

If I were a first-year college student today, I hope that the librarians would not tell me to ignore freely available online research tools in favor of books or databases. Rather, I hope they would nudge me to navigate all information sources critically and thoughtfully—including Wikipedia.

Why? Wikipedia is not perfect, but it is one of the last vestiges of an earlier, idealized vision of the World Wide Web: a place where anyone can sail the wide-open seas of human knowledge. We cannot take it for granted. Even as the information paywalls in the scholarly world continue to grow higher, Wikipedia remains an incredible resource for discovering information written by humans, for humans. In an information ecosystem dominated by corporate interests, information paywalls, and tech oligarchs, libraries must stand with Wikipedia as catalysts for a more equitable future.

Community-Centered Information Literacy for a New Era

Reflections on the power of collaboration at the LOEX Information Literacy Conference in Pasadena amid institutional uncertainty

The world shifts instantly in the opening episode of HBO’s The Last of Us. Infrastructure fails, panic erupts, and people must decide who to trust, what knowledge matters, and how to preserve what’s essential when systems collapse. But another phrase, “Look for the light,” is more than a slogan graffiti on walls. A rallying cry to the public to remember resistance against fascist rule, it also stands for a group mantra–that even in the most oppressive times, there is always hope. It is not a passive act; hope is a commitment through actions, and promise to the future. When existing structures are destroyed, the only choice is transform. So why not?

As I prepared to present at LOEX 2025: Crafting a Future for Information Literacy Conference with my colleague and mentor, Alliston Salisbury, the Undergraduate Instruction & Outreach Librarian, in Pasadena, California, I found myself drawing on apocalyptic narratives for insights on preparing for systemic disruptions. This isn’t just escapism; it reflects that our higher education mission may soon operate under radically different conditions.

LOEX’s intimate scale offered a refreshing contrast to larger gatherings like ACRL. The conference’s tight focus on information literacy created meaningful spaces for connection, reflection, and deep engagement. One session that stood out was Robin M. Katz’s workshop on primary source literacy. More than a toolkit of learning outcomes, planning templates, and assessment strategies, the session demonstrated collaborative pedagogy in action. Katz fostered active dialogue, turning the room into a temporary knowledge commons—an example of the kind of participatory learning space we’ll need more of as institutions face mounting instability.

I paid close attention not only to the content but also to how it was delivered. The distinction between passive lecture and active exchange felt more consequential than ever. It highlighted a key aspect of resilience: it’s not just about preserving access to content but cultivating networks of people who can use and adapt that knowledge in real time.

LOEX’s unique approach to conference feedback, which involves participants evaluating each session individually, is a powerful model of how resilience is built. This built-in, iterative assessment loop mirrors the adaptive learning culture we need in our institutions—responsive, granular, and continuous. LOEX reminded me that adaptation is not just an institutional process, but a profoundly personal one. While observing other sessions, I found myself questioning which presentation methods genuinely engage participants and foster active learning rather than passive consumption.

These reflections continued after my session on ASU’s collaborative tutorial project. I left with a clearer vision of how to make future presentations more participatory–how to model the very principles we aim to teach. The foundational skills of information literacy–critical thinking, flexibility, and synthesis–are not just concepts we convey to students. They are strategies we, as professionals, must adopt in how we teach, share, and evolve within shifting institutional landscapes.

The Persistence of Community

LOEX also reminded me that professional relationships are an enduring source of resilience. In the hallways between sessions, I reconnected with Hailley Fargo, a mentor from graduate school whose path I’ve long followed. That brief check-in underscored how small moments of connection strengthen our collective fabric.

Later, I was surprised and honored to see my former professor, Melissa Wong, attend. Our conversation afterward—reflecting on how the library landscape continues to shift—felt like a full-circle moment. These enduring relationships, rooted in shared experience, persist through career transitions and institutional change. In times of uncertainty, these informal networks often provide the most reliable forms of continuity. Mentors, colleagues, and peers offer grounded support that no organizational chart can fully capture. They exemplify a form of professional resilience that transcends any one institution.

Recent developments—the dismissal of Dr. Carla Hayden from the Library of Congress leadership, legislative attacks on DEI, the ongoing defunding of public information resources—are more than troubling headlines. They’re signals of a shifting foundation beneath our work.

These questions—what endures, what is preserved, and who decides—loomed quietly behind many LOEX conversations. As we presented Arizona State University (ASU’s) work developing cross-departmental, platform-agnostic tutorials for more than 145,000 students, I realized that this work isn’t only about scalability. It’s a blueprint for resilience under pressure.

Lessons from the Survivalists

Oddly enough, we may have something to learn from communities often dismissed as fringe. Survivalists ask vital questions about continuity: What skills matter when infrastructure fails? How do you pass on knowledge without institutional channels? What is truly essential to preserve?

Our work at ASU reflects this ethos. Our collaboration across departments isn’t just efficient—it’s distributed resilience. In a context without dedicated instruction departments, we’ve built cross-disciplinary partnerships to create modular, shareable, and persistent tutorials. These learning objects function across platforms and locations, embedding redundancy into the system.

In essence, our model mimics a decentralized network that can endure disruption. It offers a pathway forward, not just for scaling instruction but also for preserving knowledge when traditional structures falter.

Beyond Institutional Walls

This moment of institutional vulnerability invites us to reimagine education itself. The traditional academic model often guards access behind credentials, paywalls, and physical infrastructures. However, our work at ASU suggests another possibility: knowledge that is created once but shared widely, open, adaptable, and resilient.

If traditional degrees become less accessible or less valued, we may shift toward certifying demonstrable skills through micro-credentials. Information literacy instruction could evolve from generalized support to modular, competency-based frameworks that allow learners to build and prove expertise more flexibly.

Collaboration as a Survival Strategy

Our LOEX session on ASU’s tutorial development revealed something deeper than efficiency. When departments pool their knowledge and resources, the result is scale and structural resilience. These modular, shareable systems parallel what survivalists and game designers understand: centralized systems fail hard. Decentralized collaboration bends, adapts, and persists.

There’s unique power in bringing together professionals from different disciplines to focus on a specific project or goal. When subject librarians, instructional designers, technical specialists, and disciplinary faculty converge around information literacy, the resulting work transcends what any single perspective could produce. This cross-pollination of expertise doesn’t just create better pedagogical tools—it builds the conceptual adaptability and creative problem-solving capacity that becomes essential during institutional change. The focused inquiry that emerges from these collaborations generates solutions that are simultaneously more robust and more flexible than what siloed departments typically develop.

Higher education has long promised to prepare students for the unknown. Today, that preparation must be more literal. In a world where misinformation can destabilize democracies, information literacy becomes a civic survival skill. Teaching people how to evaluate, synthesize, and act on information becomes core to rebuilding and resilience.

This reframing elevates our work. What we shared at LOEX wasn’t just a case study—it was a distributed, durable learning design model for a world in flux. Returning from LOEX, I saw our ASU project anew. It’s more than a solution for instructional demand—it’s a knowledge preservation system, a digital campfire, a place where future learners might still gather.

In this light, collaboration is no longer a nice-to-have. It’s a survival mechanism. We weave networks not just to extend our reach but to endure. In uncertain times, our ability to creatively adapt and connect may be our most essential professional asset.

Reconsidering research impact

I have a complicated relationship with bibliometrics (i.e. “research impact metrics”).

The silhouette of a person looking at a huge swirling modern art piece on a digital screen.
Photo by Gunnar Ridderström on Unsplash

I have a complicated relationship with bibliometrics (i.e. “research impact metrics”), as does the field of academic librarianship and academia itself, if we’re honest. On one hand, there is something undeniably fascinating about how statistical formulas can help us understand “scholarship as conversation” at a macro-level. As a field, bibliometrics has been heavily influenced by information scientists. Eugene Garfield, often cited as a founder of modern bibliometrics and cocreator of Journal Citation Reports, held a degree in Library Science from Columbia University, for example, and created the infamous journal impact factor not to assess the quality of a researcher’s CV, but to help librarians make decisions about which journal subscriptions to purchase. This relationship with librarianship makes me feel some level of responsibility to/for the field of bibliometrics even if I’m not a bibliometric scholar per se. Librarians’ collection development responsibilities have traditionally positioned us as arbiters and assessors of information quality, for better or worse, which tracks with the project of research assessment.

On the other hand, several high-profile bibliometric formulas have been coopted by corporate entities to serve for-profit purposes and have been misapplied in the academe as markers of excellence for individual researchers. In the 2010s, research assessment experts denounced the use of Clarivate’s journal impact factor and overreliance on quantitative citation-based evaluation of research “impact” through statements like the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (now operating as DORA) and the Leiden Manifesto for research metrics. I share concerns cited in those statements about whether folks who use these numbers in retention, promotion, and tenure (RPT) processes can accurately explain the insight each formula is supposed to convey. Journal impact factor and Elsevier’s “CiteScore” are not generic proxies for journal quality. They aggregate citation rates over a (relatively short) period. In a vacuum, that seems like potentially useful information to consider as one part of a comprehensive assessment of a journal’s and/or a researcher’s portfolio. As a key determiner of whether a journal or its authors offer any value to the scholarly conversation, it becomes dangerous.

It is also well established that these popular metrics don’t map well across academic disciplines because different disciplines have significantly different publishing rates and citation practices, whereas metrics that normalize citation attention between disciplines like field-weighted citation impact are not commonly used in RPT procedures (from my understanding). Consequently, the perceived value of scholarship in the arts, humanities, and social sciences is diminished when their citation numbers are compared to STEM fields. In the fields that bibliometrics favor, their outsized influence in RPT processes forces faculty to “study for the test,” thereby limiting the list of suitable publication venues to a select, well-established few (often owned by one of the big five publishers). From a simple assessment standpoint, Goodhart’s law reminds us “when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.”

Although Goodhart’s law is certainly applicable to the current use of bibliometrics in academia, I think the problem requires us to zoom out a bit. The core issue leading to the misapplication of bibliometrics is academia’s attempt to assess a concept as sweeping and nebulous as “impact” using a few numbers that address one specific type of impact—contribution to the scholarly conversation.  Furthering the progress of knowledge is a valid and core reason why many scholars do research, but it certainly isn’t the only reason why people do research, and it’s not the only value that research provides to the world, so it shouldn’t be the only aspect of research impact we evaluate and thereby ascribe value to.

Of course, making any kind of structural change in academia is easier said than done for many reasons, including the entrenchment of bibliometric-based evaluation in the publishing industry and in academic tenure processes. But, there are folks exploring alternatives: in 2023, the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign introduced a Public Engagement Research Option (PERO) for Promotion and Tenure, designed for faculty who “address a societal problem to contribute to the public good; produce traditional and non-traditional outputs; collaborate with communities or organizations; [and] engage in a mutually beneficial exchange of knowledge and resources with community partners.” The HumetricsHSS Humane Metrics Initiative provides workshops and toolkit resources for academic departments to consider how they can embed their stated values in their evaluation of scholarly life, reminding us, “if we don’t measure what we value, we will only value what we can measure.” Just this month, DORA published their Practical Guide to Implementing Responsible Research Assessment at Research Performing Organizations.

I heard about that DORA resource while attending a new (to me) conference in April. The Center for Advancing Research Impact in Society hosts an annual summit around “broader impacts”—the National Science Foundation’s terminology for research’s “potential to benefit society and contribute to the achievement of specific, desired societal outcomes.” I’d been debating which research impact professional development opportunities I should explore, given that “research impact” is included in my job title. This one intrigued me because of its necessarily broad conception of impact, and I came away energized by the creative research development work happening around the world. Research development offices are logically very interested in understanding and tracking the impact of research conducted at their institutions, and they clearly spend a lot of time thinking about how to do research assessment well, and how to encourage researchers to embed the public good in their plans for research outputs. Two favorite sessions included the Association of Public & Land-grant Universities’ walk-through of “Modernizing Scholarship for the Public Good: An Action Framework for Public Research Universities,” and the Research Development team at University of Texas at Austin’s presentation on their Research-to-Policy workshops that teach faculty how to make their work accessible to legislators.

Although librarians are welcomed at the ARIS Summit, I didn’t meet any other library folks wandering between conference rooms. I mention this not to admonish anyone or toot my own horn, but rather to raise the question: why shouldn’t we participate at these types of conferences, contributing to and learning from conversations about research impact/assessment? I would argue the prevailing (mis)conception of research impact is an information literacy issue. As a librarian, I feel a responsibility to remind scholars of the ways “authority is constructed and contextual” and how our interpretations of information (like bibliometrics) influence the way those specific pieces of information come to have value. These issues are especially relevant to those of us in the scholarly communication subfield, as we play a particular role in helping scholars decide where to communicate and share their work. I now see the “open knowledge” and “research impact” components of my job title as much more intertwined that I originally thought, but it required me to conceptualize a holistic vision of research impact that incorporates the societal contribution we believe many types of scholarship can make. Academic libraries are increasingly involved at every stage of the knowledge lifecycle, and as such, I think research assessment/evaluation is an area where librarians could reconceptualize our approach, training, responsibilities, and campus partnerships.